Soil & Nutrition

Laguna Hills Nursery

 

 

lagunahillsnursery.com

(949) 830-5653

 

 

THE SOIL

A Plant and Its Requirements

          Our goal is to create the healthiest root system possible.  Without adequate roots plants will appear stressed even when irrigation and fertilization are adequate.  The major portion of a root system of a typical plant exists from the soil surface to about 8-10” deep.  Rooting depth is heavily dependent upon air penetration (the soil’s permeability).  Roots consume oxygen and release carbon dioxide just as animals do.  Roots can live deeper (10’+) in sandy or gravely soils where permeability is high.  A woody plant’s root system extends far wider than the plant is tall.  A 20 year-old tree often has roots that reach 100’ away, but rarely more than 2’ deep.  Plants require from the soil the following:

  1. Water storage
  2. Oxygen and gas exchange
  3. Nutrient (minerals) storage
  4. Support
  5. Insulation from heat and cold

If any of the above is lacking symptoms of stress occur.  These include:

  1. Small foliage and stunted growth
  2. Off-colored or dull foliage
  3. Yellow and brown-edged foliage
  4. Branch dieback
  5. The plant develops a lean

 

What is Soil?

Soil in a complex mixture combining material derived from rock (mineral) along with air, water and organic material. 

Soil is typically a 3-layered cake in profile.  The top layer is called the topsoil.  The middle layer is the subsoil and the bottom layer is the parent material.  These layers rest on the bedrock.  Any of these layers can be a fraction of an inch to several feet thick.  Generally the cake is 3’-6’ deep.  We are mostly concerned with the topsoil.

Unfortunately local homebuilders are not required to save and put back the topsoil after a home is completed.  Owners of new homes often have to work with parent material or even bedrock. 

Loam is the term given to topsoil containing all 3 of the major particle sizes:  SAND, SILT, and CLAY. 

  1. Sand-particles from 2mm-0.1mm
  2. Silt-particles from 0.05mm-0.002mm
  3. Clay-flakes less than 0.002mm

The percent volume of these 3 components can range from nearly 100% to nearly 0%.  The presence of all three is required to create good growing conditions.  Without sand there is very little airflow.  Without clay there is very little moisture or nutrient retention.  A good loam has a sand:silt:clay ratio of about 40:40:20.  Soils that are mostly sand, by virtue of the empty spaces between particles, are lighter than clay soils. 

Actually clay soils contain more space (higher porosity) but this space is normally always filled with water molecules.  A sack of kiln-dried clay weighs less than a sack of kiln-dried sand, but natural clay soil is heavier.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          

Soils containing high volumes of sand are called “light” soils.  Soils with significant percentages of clay are called “heavy” soils. 

Clay absorbs more water adding to its weight.  Clay can hold 2” of water per foot while sand only holds about ½”.  Water molecules are strongly attracted to soil particles in a layer one molecule thick.  The collective surface area of the particles doubles when the particle size decreases by half.  The water holding potential of the soil is called its field capacity.  Mineral nutrients dissolved in water also accumulate to a higher extent in soils with a higher field capacity. 

Sandy Loam is a technical term for the soil type that farmers prefer.  It is a mixture of sand:silt:clay in a ratio that is roughly 6:3:1.  Compared to loam, a sandy loam has higher permeability (airflow) for more vigorous roots but looses some nutrient and water retention. 

It doesn’t require a high percentage of clay for a loam soil to be considered a clay loam.  When the clay content reaches just over 30% it completely fills all the gaps between the larger particles and permeability declines dramatically. 

The gaps that exist between soil particles are where air and water can move and be stored.  If the soil particles were uniform in size and perfect spheres the unfilled space would be 36%. 

Permeability (often incorrectly called the porosity) represents the ease of gas (air) exchange.  Each type of plant has a minimum value that they can remain vigorous in.  Most easy-to-grow plants get by with low permeability.  Conversely just about any plant that has a reputation for being difficult requires high permeability.  The table below represents the lowest volume of the soil occupied by air that that list of plants can tolerate.

     2-5%            Conifer, Palm, Rose, Turf

     5-10%          Hydrangea, Lily, Mum

     10-20%        Begonia, Gardenia

     20%+           Azalea, Fern, Orchid

Nature can improve permeability of heavy soils.  Lignin (the glue that holds a plant together) is released into the soil when dead leaves or any other plant tissue decomposes on the surface.  Lignin along with the activity of soil bacteria glues the smaller clay particles into large clumps (granulation, agglutination) that act like building blocks.  Worms (macroscopic and microscopic), amoebas and other small organisms create airways.  There are fungi called Mycorrhizae (see page 4) associated with nearly all plants that grow a network of hyphae (fungal strands resembling roots) that hold everything together like the girders of a building.  Living soils in a well-established plant community look similar to Swiss cheese in cross section and resist compaction. 

                Humus is the organic matter found in Nature’s soils.  Humus is essentially inert.  It is either charcoal or plant fibers that won’t decompose further.  In Nature’s soils the humus content ranges from less than 1% to just less than 3%.  Humus, especially charcoal, holds on to nutrients better than any other material found in Nature.  The rich black soils found in many areas around the World are due to charcoal deposited after wildfires.  Just a small amount (2-3%) of charcoal makes the soils appear black and become mineral rich. 

 

Drainage

            Drainage is the ability of the soil to relieve itself of a saturated condition.  Saturated soils have all spaces filled with water, making gas exchange very poor.  Roots don’t require as much oxygen as animals but certain species will suffocate if the water stagnates for more than 35 hours. (By this time the roots and other soil dwelling organisms have consumed all the oxygen available in the water.) Chronically saturated soil results in a very shallow root system.  Root rot diseases are promoted when oxygen levels drop.  Plants would much rather grow in soils that are moist but not saturated. 

Note that just about any small plant will survive indefinitely with their roots sitting in a bucket of clean water.  The oxygen circulates freely when the water movement is not impeded by soil particles. 

                Poor drainage can be due to:

  1. Water applied into the soil faster than it can drain.
  2. The soil below is hardpan or bedrock and won’t drain at all.
  3. There is a sudden change in soil texture in a layer below, resulting in a perched water table.  (See next column)

Farmers like soils that have good drainage at least 6’ deep. 

                Drainage can be improved for extended periods either by:

  1. Installing a French drain (not very effective with clay soils)
  2. Digging a dry well
  3. Raising the entire bed
  4. Breaking up any hard pan.

 

Misconceptions About Soil

Be aware that many of the symptoms of poor drainage and/or overwatering can be attributed to the fairly recent tradition of amending the native soil with significant amounts of compost or organic mulches.  This standard practice can only benefit annual row crops involving plants that are harvested in less than 6 months, or incredibly permeable soil where oxygen availability is excellent, but water and nutrient retention are lacking.   Compost lowers the oxygen level of the soil with which it is mixed with usually resulting in a shallow, sparse or unhealthy root system.  If compost has any nutritional value it is still capable of decomposing and consuming oxygen.  When it is finished decomposing there is virtually no volume remaining. 

                A heavy soil often turns black after it is amended with a lot of compost.  This black color is due to the presence of sewer gasses (like hydrogen sulfide) that form when decomposition occurs under low oxygen levels.  This is poisonous to the roots.  A black soil created by adding compost instead of charcoal is dead, not rich!

                There are soils in nature that are 100% organic.  These are called peat bogs and they contain muck.  Nothing will grow due to the lack of oxygen penetration.  This lifeless condition can exist for thousands of years.

 

Soil in a Container

Containers present certain problems not encountered when growing in the ground. 

  1. Built-in perched water table.  Soil is normally like an endless sponge with any excess water continuously transferring downward.  If it is interrupted by a horizontal layer of gravel some of the water will perch in a saturated zone above the gravel.  This is because soil can exert a stronger pull on the water molecules than gravel or gravity.  Similarly, if the bottom of a container is made of a non-porous material, gravity cannot, even with plenty of drain holes, relieve the soil at the bottom of a pot from a saturated condition.  The height (above the bottom) of this saturated soil is dependent upon the coarseness of the soil.  The smaller the particles, the higher the porosity and the higher the saturation after irrigation.  To provide good growing conditions, either the pot must be tall, leaving an adequate volume of unsaturated soil above the perched water table, or the soil must be very coarse creating a thinner layer of saturated soil.  If the plant uses a tremendous volume of water a high perched water table can be beneficial.  Generally low containers are more difficult to manage because the perched water table is closer to the top.  Taller containers provide a larger zone of moist unsaturated soil following a thorough irrigation. 
  2. Lack of moisture reserve.  Unlike the ground, plants only have access to moisture in the container no matter how hard the roots can suck.  Container design (self-watering pots) and irrigation timing can get around this problem. 
  3. Poor retention of nutrients.  Clay and charcoal hold nutrients best.  The coarse soil in pots allows nutrients to get washed out quickly.  Organic or slow release fertilizers help, as well as adding an organic mulch layer or leonardite (a material that resembles charcoal) to the soil. 
  4. Lack of insulation.  Exposure to summer sun and to winter cold can cause root damage and death.  Pots can be shielded or moved into protected areas.

 

History of Potting Soils and Organic Amendments

            Bonsai, the art of growing miniature but mature looking trees in small pots has been a part of Japan for nearly a thousand years.  The traditional methods use natural soil ingredients.  The masters considered sand the most vigorous growing medium, but had to curtail vigor (Bonsai plants need to be stunted) by adding certain amounts of loam (with silt and clay).  If problems were encountered the soil was changed to pure sand until the plant recovered. 

                During the 19th century Citrus were grown in huge pots in France.  The trees spent warm weather outdoors but were moved into Orangeries (primitive heated greenhouses) for the winter.  The soil in these pots was about 97% sand.

                In the early 20th century the Royal Horticultural Society determined that sandy loam was the most ideal soil for containers. 

                In the late 1950’s I played in my father’s pile of container soil.  The soil was a sandy loam with almost no clay.  Local building supply yards carry a similar product called fill sand.  This soil gives decent results for 5-gallon and larger containers.  My father told me that growing plants was simple.  He watered his plants every day and fertilized them every month with excellent results.  The number of plant species grown 50 years ago does not come close to what is offered today, however my father seemed to grow Gardenias, Camellias, Avocados, and Citrus with little difficulty. 

                In the 1950’s the University of California developed several soil mixes for containers that would be lighter (more consumer friendly) and even more permeable.  Among these are

    1. 1 part sand:1 part peat
    2. 1 part sand:1 part bark
    3. 2 part sand:1 part bark:1 part peat

In the 1960’s my father added redwood sawdust to his sandy loam to lighten it.  This worked well as redwood decays very slowly.  A number of growers still use a redwood/sand mix. 

In the 1970’s redwood became quite expensive and fir shavings, fir bark and other materials became quite prevalent.  By the 1980’s we were having many problems with rotting rots in potted plants.  The agricultural agents told my father that he shouldn’t be watering his plants every day, even though he had done that for nearly 30 years. 

In that same decade, the Ball Seed Company’s book, The Ball Red Book, (still a Bible for greenhouse flower growers) warns that while peat, sawdust, and bark are fine for growing annuals, permanent plants require permanent materials for best long term results.  “A balance between water-holding capacity and air-supplying power should be sought.  Of the two aeration is more important.”  Apparently few growers listened.

In the 1980’s the prominent horticulturalists were pushing the theory that the more compost you incorporate into the soil, the better the results.  In those days I followed their lead, but was starting to notice puzzling results.  In the late 1980’s and early 1990’s I did not trust that what we were telling customers worked at all.  Plants were rotting and everyone was blaming too much irrigation.  I could not predict what our customer’s results would be.  Growing plants was getting strangely mysterious. 

In 1995 I talked to a soil researcher who explained that soil was not organic.  The scientist had me slowly strip off the soil from a plant that was growing in a bark and peat-based potting soil.  He told me to observe careful.  During the purging process the plant quite noticeably “pulled” its leaves up and looked much “happier” as the organic matter was removed.  That same year I started growing vegetables (broccoli, strawberry, artichoke) in pure sand and pure pumice and saw incredible results.  Growing plants in pumice is a form of Hydroponics.

The European Hothouse industry spent a lot of research money to determine the best materials (substrates) to use in their hothouses for their crops.  Greenhouse operations are so costly that it is imperative that the plants grow and produce at the highest levels possible.  They recommended sand, perlite, pumice, rock wool, pelletized clay, peat moss, coconut coir and rice hulls as dependable materials. 

Perlite and pumice are both silicon dioxide (same material as glass) that have a lot of air pockets.  Perlite is a mined ore that is popped in an oven like popcorn.  Pumice is made by Nature in volcanoes by gasses blowing through moulten rock.  Rice hulls are actually quite similar being about 90% silicon and are used as a perlite substitute.  Rockwool is a thick sheet of mineral fibers commonly spun from basalt.  Pelletized clay are fired (stable) clay pellets somewhat larger than sand.  Peat Moss, which is composed of hair-like plant fibers, will retain its form and character for at least several months.  Coconut coir, the fiber from Coconut shells, is similar but not quite as water retentive as peat moss. 

All of these materials are available at a reasonable cost, have well-documented characteristics, and are extremely permeable.  The high permeability promotes explosive root and plant growth, but the grower has to irrigate and fertilize carefully and constantly.  All of these materials are discarded and replaced periodically. 

The hothouse researchers determined that the characteristics of wood, bark, green waste and other types of organic products (ground up pallets, etc.) to be unpredictable.  This means that they could not get consistent results when using wood, bark or other “bio” materials as a growing medium.  The characteristics of wood and bark vary greatly from tree to tree, even from one end of the plank to the other end. 

Currently most of the large growers of container plants in the U.S. use lots of partially composted ground bark (either Fir or Pine).  These plants can look great initially, although rarely as good as field-grown plants.  One university researcher, who recommends fir bark, reminds growers that bark is a good growing medium for a 5-month period following 3 months of initial composting.  After 5 months the substrate has lost much of its permeability and the lack of oxygen also causes the continuing decomposition to produce toxic substances.  He recommends that within 5 months make certain that the plant has been either:

1.       Sold

2.       Moved into a larger container surrounded with fresh bark, or

3.       Discarded.

It appears to me that this researcher considers landscape plants to be the same as florists’ plants.  Sell and/or discard.

                I believe that growers honestly think that organic materials become good soil somehow and/or become replaced by the surrounding soil once installed.  When these plants are planted into extremely free breathing soils like the coarse soils found in the inland valleys, the results are decent.  However, if these same plants are planted into heavy soils typical of Orange County, they act as if they are growing in a pocket of sewage.  I have observed that the fastest growing plants are least affected, probably because their roots have become so large that the comparatively small pocket of sludge has little effect. 

                In the retail market there are a wide range of nationwide brand name and locally bagged potting soils.  A few years ago a UC researcher studied a number of these potting soils.  There results showed that most brands killed most of the species of trial plants.  Only one plant (Impatiens) survived in all the soils.  Among the brands tested the Scott’s (aka Miracle Gro) had the best results.  The researcher pointed out that these soils are meant to perform for 6 months.  The main ingredients in Scott’s is peat moss and composted forest products (wood and/or bark pieces)..

                Our custom potting soils also contain peat moss.  However our 2 soils are 50%:50% peat:pumice and 60%:30%:10% pumice:peat:sand.  Our soils perform much better after 1 year than the others primarily because they contain much more material that is permanent. 

                Pure sand is still the best long term potting soil (for pots taller than 12”) but the weight can be a problem.  At my home we like a mixture of roughly 50% sand, 25% peat, and 25% pumice.  This is essentially mixing plaster sand with our Laguna Hills Nursery Acid Mix Potting Soil in equal parts.  The plants that we grow here at our store are grown in a very similar soil. 

                You may note that our soils do not have much nutritional value.  This leads us to my next rule.

 

Fertilize Organically

What are Plants Made Of?

            All plants contain the following minerals:

  1. Carbon  C
  2. Hydrogen  H
  3. Oxygen  O
  4. Phosphorus  P
  5. Potassium  K
  6. Nitrogen  N
  7. Sulfur  S
  8. Calcium  Ca
  9. Iron  Fe
  10. Magnesium  Mg
  11. Boron  B
  12. Manganese  Mn
  13. Copper  Cu
  14. Zinc  Zn
  15. Molybdenum  Mo
  16. Chlorine  Cl
  17. Nickel  Ni

Their relative abundance is roughly the same order, although a few will change places depending upon the type of plant or the age of it.  Young plants are higher in nitrogen.  Older plants collect calcium as part of their wood.  Animal bodies contain 16 of the 17 minerals found in plants.  Some plants contain more than 17 minerals, though in many they may not be essential. 

                The main structure of a mature plant is the cell wall (cellulose a.k.a. wood), a converted sugar molecule containing H, C, and O.  The cell membranes are mostly protein which is made of C,H,O, and N.  The sap contains water and a significant amount of K.  Most of the other minerals are involved in energy capture and transfer, or with enzymes. 

                Four of these are found in air or water and need not be added.  We need to be aware of the presence of 13.  Most homeowners cannot juggle these with any sense of accuracy. 

                The majority of farmers use chemical fertilizers.  Farmers get their soil and/or their plants analyzed periodically by laboratories.  Soil lab technicians have stated that it is nearly impossible to guess what mineral is missing by the appearance of the foliage.  If you apply the wrong mineral the problem is often compounded.  An overabundance of one will often block the uptake of another.  The soil lab’s technicians tell the farmers what minerals are needed and how much to apply typically one mineral at a time. 

                Many homeowners apply a “complete” chemical fertilizer that has N, P and K.  Of course, these are not truly complete.  If you only apply 3, or any number less than13 the plants will eventually become chlorotic (anemic), pale in color due to a lack of one of the essential 13 minerals.   Typically it is a mineral involved with the chlorophyll molecule and contributes to the normal green color of the leaves.  I have yet to find any single chemical fertilizer that has 13 minerals.  On the other hand, most organic fertilizers have all 17 minerals.  This is because organic fertilizers contain dead plants and/or animals.

                The reason why chemical fertilizers remain in heavier use is that:

  1. Up until now they have been inexpensive to produce from petroleum.
  2. They are more concentrated, thus lighter to ship and easier to apply.
  3. They are more soluble and usually work faster.
  4. They don’t smell bad and don’t harbor diseases. 

The use of organic fertilizers is catching up quickly.  This is because:

  1. This is what most plants were designed to use.
  2. Organic matter feeds the soil and keeps the soil alive and healthy.  Exclusive use of chemicals eventually kills the soil. 
  3. All the nutrients are present and chlorosis (nutrient imbalance) is rare. 
  4. Organic fertilizers are slow release, less likely to burn and pollute.

 

How Plants in Nature Acquire Minerals

            The majority of plants in Nature are recyclers.  95% of known plant species utilize a symbiotic fungus known as Mycorrhizae.  This soil dwelling organism breaks down the duff (layer of fallen leaves, stems, etc.) and returns the minerals to the plants.  Mycorrhizae were discovered to exist only a few decades ago.  Mycorrhizal fungal hyphae, the bulk of the fungus organism, are very difficutl to distinguish from plant roots and are intimately connected to the roots of plants.  Mycorrhizae essentially increase the surface area of a plant’s roots capable of collecting water and nutrients five fold.  A well-known variety is the Truffle, which is attached to certain Oak trees in France.  In this symbiotic relationship the plants supplies the fungus with carbohydrates (energy) and the fungus provides minerals (building material).  The fungus also protects the roots from attack by diseases.  A single Mycorrhizal fungi organism can connect the roots of many different plants together.  This allows the plants to share nutrients and water.  Most plants aren’t particular about which species of Mycorrhizae that they associate with.  A few plants (notably Azalea, Manzanita) use specific types of Mycorrhizae and cannot easily be grown without them.  Although Mycorrhizal fungi are a featured addition to many fertilizer products they rarely need to be applied. 

                There are a number of plant species that are called pioneer plants.  These are specialized plants, like Wild Mustard, that evolved to live on the availability of soil nutrients in certain areas.  They have no need for Mychorrizal fungus.  They usually appear following a fire (that releases nutrients from the plants into mineral form) or new soil deposits (from landslides or fresh river sediment).  Pioneer plants gather the available nutrients with a highly evolved fine textured root system.  The minerals are concentrated into the foliage of these plants.  As soon as these plants have produced ample dead foliage the recyclers can take over and the pioneer plants die out only too reappear following the next fire. 

                In most climax ecosystems the soil no longer contains significant amounts of available nutrients.  Everything the plants could extract is now either in the living plants or in the duff layer on the ground.  In forests and especially in rainforests, where wildfires are rare, the soil is essentially devoid of minerals useful to the plants.  The only way to recover the minerals is to burn the trees down.   

                A few decades ago the U of California Davis did a survey of the Central Valley flora to see how the different soil textures, pH, and nutrient availabilities affected the plant species.  Their conclusion was that it made no difference.  Wherever there was a good accumulation of fallen leaves from the native trees the same species of plants grew.  These plants apparently just recycle nutrients independent of the soil’s characteristics.

 

Compost Versus Duff

            Mycorrhizal fungi recycle the nutrients found in duff, a layer of plant debris.  It is essentially a closed system.  The nutrients freed by the fungus are primarily available to the plants the fungus is associated with.  Most perennial woody plants depend on this fungus recycling system.

                When plant debris is recycled by the compost method it involves bacteria.  The bacteria consume the debris and nutrients are released freely into the soil when the bacteria later die.  Most annuals and many grasses depend upon this compost recycling system. 

                The two systems can exist together but aren’t good neighbors.  Bacteria can kill fungi.  When I use my chipper to chip and shred plant debris I no longer allow it to compost.  I’m hoping that the garden will get fewer weeds (most weeeds are non-Mycorrhizal plants) if the Mycorrhizae dominate. 

 

Mulch Deeply

            Plants are much healthier when the ground around them is covered with an organic mulch.  We recommend 2” to 3” deep.  Deeper is fine if the mulch is coarse.  (Do not mix the mulch with the soil below.)  Compared with bare soil, a deep covering of mulch accomplishes the following:

1.       Releases nutrients constantly.

2.       Provides a home for beneficial soil organisms. 

3.       The products of decomposition along with the action of soil organisms improves soil permeability. 

4.       Improves absorption of rainfall and irrigation.

5.       Slows evaporation.

6.       Insulates the soil from excessive heat or cold.

7.       Prevents germination of (weed) seeds. 

As organic mulches decompose they provide both minerals and energy to the soil organisms.  Previously it was thought that minerals from a dead leaf were recycled within 2 years through bacterial compost recycling.  Research has shown this time to be as little as 3 months using the fungus recycling system. 

                Certain types of mulches resist breakdown and serve longer as a cover.  Redwood sawdust and bark can last well over 5 years.  Cedar lasts nearly as long.  Large chunks of Fir Bark last many years but finely ground bark may disappear within 2 years.  Chopped up plant clippings from my garden disappear within a year.  Mulches that last longer release nutrients slower. 

                I’ve seen a thick layer of redwood sawdust totally stop erosion on a steep slope.  Water from sprinklers and rain moves tiny clay particles easily but can’t seem to budge coarse gravel, sand or mulches. 

                In Texas scientists compared soil temperatures 1’ deep in an orchard with bare soil and an orchard covered with 3” of mulch.  With an air temperature of 90°F the soil in the mulched orchard was 85°F.  The soil in the bare orchard was 110°F.  That’s a 25-degree difference!  Most plant roots do not function well much above 86°F. 

                Mulches allow a plant to have a much larger root system.  Without mulch the soil close to the surface is too hot and dry.  With mulch the roots can inhabit the zone up to the soil surface where there is more oxygen. 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Planting

Replanting

& Irrigation

10-02-09

Laguna Hills Nursery

25290 Jeronimo Road

Lake Forest, California 92630

lagunahillsnursery.com

(949) 830-5653

 

 

From Container

Working With The Native Soil

                First of all let’s assume that the plant we are going to install is perfect, otherwise you may have to fix it before it is planted (see Repairing Plants).  Let’s also assume that your garden’s soil is at least decent, not solid rock or solid clay. 

            You may want to check you soil for drainage before you start. 

  1. Dig a hole 18” deep and wide. 
  2. Fill with water.
  3. If it drains within 10 minutes the drainage is above average.
  4. If it drains within 1 day the drainage is good.
  5. If the hole still has water after several days you should select bog tolerant plants or fix the drainage. 

 

                The goal is to keep all the roots alive while they are getting established.  The problem is that many of the deeper roots that come with the container plant are too deep to breathe in our local soil (especially when you install plants that were grown in containers taller than 8”).  This problem is also due to the fact that the drain holes at the bottom of the containers gave the roots an unnaturally deep source of air.  The ground has no such air source.  We have to provide sufficient airflow to the bottom of the planting hole to keep the deep roots alive. 

                Small container plants (up to 8” deep) have such shallow root balls that it is not critical to create a breathable zone.  They get enough air from the surface passing through their own root ball. 

                For a larger container plant we recommend:

  1. The soil is easier to work with if it is moist but not wet.  Thoroughly irrigating the area 2-3 days before is quite beneficial during the dry season.
  2. Dig a hole as deep as the root ball is tall.  Don’t make it deeper.  We don’t want any chance that the top of the root ball will sink below surface level. 
  3. Dig the hole wide enough so that there would be a gap of about 4-6” from the edge of the root ball to the edge of the hole. 
  4. Mix the soil you dug out of the hole with about 1/3 to 1/2 of either:
    1. Laguna Hills Nursery Planting mix
    2. Laguna Hills Nursery Tropical Potting Soil.
    3. Laguna Hills Nursery Acid Mix
    4. Pumice

All of our soil mixes contain pumice, the most efficient material at aerating the soil.  It is best not to backfill with pure product although it can work.  We are creating a halfway house and want the roots to enter the native soil fairly quickly. 

  1. Place the plant into the hole. 
  2. Place the amended soil into the hole around the root ball.  Firm the soil with your hands to eliminate air pockets.  When installing large plants of 15-gallon or larger, it is beneficial to place perforated pipes vertically along side the root ball to provide even easier air passage to the bottom.  A section of 3” perforated drain pipe works fine.  It can be filled with gravel to stop mosquitoes and capped with a drain grate for safety. 
  3. Use the remaining loose soil to build a 2-3” high basin around the plant to catch irrigation water.  Make certain that native soil does not cover the surface of the plant’s root ball.   (The relatively high porosity and low permeability of native soil will prevent irrigation water from entering the root ball.)
  4. Water thoroughly.  Fill the water basin at least 3 times.  It takes several inches of moisture to thoroughly moisten dry soil.  The soil is adequately moist only during or just following our December-April rainy season. 
  5. During warm weather (80ºF+) the newly installed plant should be watered daily or even several times per day if the weather approaches 100ºF.  Once the roots have had time to grow into the surrounding soil daily watering is less critical.  This may be just a few days for plants smaller than 1-gallon, a few weeks for 1 to 5-gallon sizes, and a month or more for larger specimens.  Plants are established once they grow a significant amount of root into the surrounding soil. 
  6. After a few weeks the basin can be smoothed out if the plant is watered with sprinklers or drip.  Apply an organic surface mulch to stop weeds, insulate the soil, provide nutrition and conserve water.

 

Replacing the Native Soil

            If the soil in the planting bed is essentially rock or pure clay you will get better results if better soil is brought in.  Here are 3 strategies:

  1. Add a layer of soil on top of the existing soil.  I recommend either sandy loam or a mixture of sandy loam : decomposed granite.  The thicker the layer the better, but 6”-8” is enough to give positive results.
  2. Build raised planters in strategic locations and fill with the soils listed above.
  3. Remove 8” to 2’ of native soil and replace with the soils listed above.  It’s a good idea to install French Drains in the lowest sections to insure that marshes don’t develop. 

The plants can then be installed using the previous instructions. 

Here are a few precautions:

  1. If your home is near a slope consult a soil engineer to make certain you won’t cause slope failure.  If a highly porous soil is substituted, the ground near a slope may absorb too much water and become unstable.
  2. If you add soil make certain the yard’s surface drainage is not affected.  Do not cover any portion of the house’s walls. 

 

Amend the Native Soil

            If your soil is heavy clay the permeability can be increased if the entire bed is amended.  (Amending the soil cannot improve drainage.)  Adding pumice is the most efficient (adds less volume) and permanent method.  To be effective the pumice should be from 10-20% of volume.  This is 1”-2” of pumice mixed in with 9”-8” of soil to create 10” of highly permeable earth.  This can be fairly expensive. 

                Sand can be added to increase permeability, however, depending upon the clay content of the soil, you may have to increase the sand content of the soil anywhere from 10% to nearly 70% to change the soil’s character. 

 

Soil For Lawns

                According to studies by the University of Texas all turf grasses perform best on the native soil regardless of how poor unless the native soil is gravel or rock.  Organic amendments do not improve the results.  In fact we have seen the exact opposite.  Amending with organic materials may produce better results initially but will ultimately result in a shallow root system making the lawn very sensitive to cold, heat, and drought.  You can also expect mushrooms to appear for several years as they feed upon the decaying organic matter.  I also believe that organic soil amendments make the lawn susceptible to Pythium, a disease that has become problematic in the last 15 years.  If you are determined to add organic matter, amend with a product containing leonardite, such as GroPower or John & Bob’s Soil Optimizer.  Leonardite, also known as humic acids, is an inert form of carbon that will help the soil store nutrients. 

                If you soil has been artificially compacted (construction equipment, vehicle traffic, excessive play, etc.) it is beneficial to turn over or till the area.  Dry soil should be well irrigated several days before tilling to soften it.  After tilling the soil should be smoothed out and firmed using a landscape rake and water roller (or by walking on it).  The correct firmness is when, walking over the soil, your heels sink but your toes don’t.  The soil is now ready for sod or seed. 

                If you are intent on creating turf for constant use, such as a sports field, there is a different approach.  To prevent compaction the top 2 feet of soil is replaced with sand.  Below the sand a drainage system is installed.  During the warm months turf growing on sand is irrigated nightly. 

 

Choose a Good Plant

                Now that you have good soil in your garden it is up to you to get the best plant possible.  The best plant may not be the most convenient, or the easiest.  Here’s my list in descending order:

  1. Seed  Best because it is natural.  Seed-grown plants always have the best roots, the best branching structure and ultimately the quickest growth, however not everything is easy to grow from seed and many desired plants are hybrids or selections that are not reliably obtained in seed form.  Also most homeowners and homeowner associations want larger plants installed.
  2. Bulb  Excellent but only a fraction of plants are obtained as a bulb. 
  3. Balled & Burlapped  Excellent.  This is the best way to get a desirable woody shrub or tree.  These plants are grown in the ground for several years.  When sold they are dug up with burlap holding the roots and soil together.  The transplanted plants perform as if they had grown on site all of their life.  Unfortunately less than 10% of landscape plants are grown this way today. 
  4. Bare Root  Excellent.  Quite a few ornamental trees and bushes and fruit trees and vine are planted as Bare Root.  Similar to Balled & Burlapped but the soil is removed and many small roots are lost.  Not suitable for large specimens (due to current harvesting techniques) but excellent results with smaller specimens of many plants.  However, nearly all are deciduous plants (a few conifers and misc.) and only available for 3-4 months of the year. 
  5. Container Good to Poor.  The soil in containers is not only has a vastly different texture than your garden soil, it also usually contains a significant amount of compost.  Younger plants in smaller containers are preferable.  The soil on 1-gallon up to 5-gallon can be changed.  (See below)  It is difficult to detect a root crown defect (sharply circling roots) caused by confinement in containers.  It may be difficult to determine what type of wood or bark product was incorporated by the grower.  (Decay resistant materials give better results.)  Different growers use much different soil mixes and get varying results.  The specimen with the largest leaves usually is the healthiest at that moment.

 

Repair a Plant Growing in Bad Soil

            Although it is a better strategy to find a perfect plant, sometimes what you desire is only grown in temporary (non-permanent) soil.  You can purge a container-grown plant that is growing in improper soil.  This involves removing all, or at least 50%, of the growers potting medium and replacing it with a more permanent, more natural soil.  Before starting you may need to have a location that will provide shade while rehabilitating the plant. 

                The danger faced with purging a leafy plant is that the roots are always damaged and water uptake is compromised for up to 1-2 weeks following the procedure.  Leaves use (lose) water; the rest of the plant (stems and woody structures) loses very little.  During the time it takes for the roots to regenerate, the leafy plant can totally dehydrate to death, especially if exposed to hot, dry conditions.  If the purged plant is placed in a shady, humid location (under a bush or low tree) its water needs will be lessened.  Removal of a significant amount of foliage or cutting back foliated stems will also lessen the water usage.

                Deciduous plants are easy to purge without stressing in the winter during dormancy.  They can also be done in summer if at least 90% of the foliage is removed. 

            Tropical plants are best purged in summer.  Be sure to remove at least 90% of the leaves before starting if no shade is available.  Houseplants are simply left indoors away from direct sun. 

                There are several techniques used to purge the roots of the wrong soil mix:

  1. Attach a spray nozzle to your garden hose.  A strong jet with relatively low water volume is quite efficient.   
  2. Use a sharp tool, such as a small size screwdriver, a sharpened chopstick or an ice pick, to loosen the soil around the roots and pick out large chunks of wood or bark.  Often poking and prying the root ball from the bottom will result in a lot of material quickly falling away from the roots.  It is important to take your time and preserve as much of the delicate root system as possible.  For this method the soil should be moist but not wet.  Dry soil is very firm and difficult to penetrate and wet soil may collapse suddenly in large pieces taking roots with it. 
  3. Combine both methods.  I usually probe with a stick first and finish with water. 

Once the roots are clean make certain they remain wet until replanted.  You may be surprised at how few roots some plants are surviving with. 

If you wish to retain more foliage the plants should be repotted into better soil and placed in the shade for a minimum of 2 weeks until the roots have recovered.  

If there are few or no leaves the plant can be installed in its final location immediately.  Set the plant in a hole at the proper depth, carefully surround the roots with pulverized native soil (try to keep the roots within 4-6 inches of the surface) and water repeatedly (minimum of 3 times) until it can be certain that the roots and surrounding soil are wet.  Make certain the plant doesn’t lean as the soil settles. 

You may wish to supply a mild fertilizer at the same time.  During the growing season expect plants to initiate new growth within 2 weeks of when the soil was purged. 

When plants are put into better soil you will notice that the new leaves are larger and greener and that the plants suffer less stress.  When I have changed the soil on Bougainvilleas going dormant for the winter they awaken and become evergreen plants (like they should be) and bloom throughout the year.  The Gardenias we have purged also begin to bloom all year!

Plants already in the ground can also be repaired, but with larger specimens you may only want to work on a portion of the root system at a time. 

 

The Replant Syndrome & Crop Rotation

                Farmers rotate their crops.  For example Tomatoes are usually planted once every 3 years (a 3-year cycle).  Roses for the bare root trade are grown on a 5-year cycle.  Roses take 2 years to harvest and other crops are grown for the next 3 years.  Farmers rotate to avoid having to deal with the diseases and pests associated with the remains of the last crop. 

                The ground surrounding any living plant will accumulate dead roots of that plant over time.  When an annual farm crop is harvested there is suddenly a lot of dead and dying roots of that crop.  If the same or related plant is installed immediately, it will be stunted, often severely, fighting diseases associated with the decaying root tissue.  Unrelated plants are generally not affected. 

                Lets talk about Tomato farming in more detail.  You can grow Tomato plants for 2 or even 3 consecutive years, but each year the yield is less and the plant shows less vigor and more yellow foliage.  By the 3rd year the yield may not justify the crop.  Without sufficient time between crops the volume of dead Tomato root is increasing faster than it is decomposing along with the associated diseases.  Tomato plants may not grow well for another 4-5 years.  If the crop is only planted every 3rd year the carry over of dead tomato root and the associated diseases becomes insignificant.  The farmer makes certain that the in-between crops are not related to tomatoes. 

                Crop rotation can also be called the replant syndrome and I have seen literature discussing this phenomenon in Rose gardens and Apple orchards. 

                Farms can get around crop rotation with soil sterilization using fumigation.  Fumigation apparently neutralizes the build up of dead tissue. 

                Forestry experts know that a severe fire will renew the forest.  Cooking the soil, even just the top foot or so, is enough to allow regrowth of the same trees.  Surveys have shown that in rainforests (where fires are rare) 2 trees of the same species are separated by an average of 175 yards.  Lack of fires (and lack of Ice Age glaciers) results in much more diversity in rain forests than in drier areas. 

                Some plants are much more tolerant of replanting than others.  Grasses are highly tolerant, however, the first time a lawn species is planted it shows the most vigor. 

                If you desire to replant immediately you can always rotate the soil instead.  In Apple orchards replacement of ½ cubic yard (3 feet by 3 feet by 18 inches deep) of soil (from a location away from the Apple trees) gives excellent results.  In Rose gardens replacing about 1 cubic foot of soil gives good results.  If the plant being installed has its own soil ball the replacement volume can be reduced.

                You must also do that same soil replacement when installing a plant within the root zone of an existing related plant, such as, when squeezing in a new rose plant in-between older, established rose bushes. 

                Double-digging a bed is another method of soil rotation.  The top 12” layer of soil is exchanged with the 12” layer directly below it.  Because plants don’t root much deeper than 12”, the underlying layer will contain very few roots of the previous crop. 

                The replant syndrome is related to plant longevity. 

            Penstemons are known to perform well in the same soil for about 3 years.  After that period they falter and eventually die.  Simply replanting the same plant a few feet away can rejuvenate them.  Our container growers have told me that during winter they cut them down, pull them out and put them back into the same container with fresh soil for another year of good vigor.  Also, Penstemons are usually propagated with stem cuttings.  This is equivalent to putting virgin soil around an old plant (the cutting). 

                The replant syndrome in plants is analogous to human public health practices.  Human babies cannot thrive if in close proximity to dead tissue of other humans.  There is little or no effect if the dead tissue is fish, mouse, snail or insect.  There is also little effect if the dead human tissue is cooked or cremated. 

 

Irrigation Practices

                Plants need average to ample water to perform.  Many plants are drought tolerant and/or drought resistant.  Even these, however, prefer average to ample water to perform the following:

  1. Germinate from seed.
  2. Get established following transplant.
  3. Grow.
  4. Bloom, and or set fruit.
  5. Produce viable seed or good quality fruit.

There are certain plants that can thrive with less than average water but the majority of plants will, at minimum, stop growing.  Many drought tolerant plants in Nature will only grow, flower and reproduce following a significant rain event or an unusually wet season. 

                In an established garden that is composed mostly of foliage plants, keeping the soil somewhat dry during the summer can be beneficial because of less pruning. 

                Lawns, flowering plants, vegetables and fruit trees require average to ample moisture. 

Be aware that mature bushes and trees can have extensive roots that can capture water over 100 feet away and therefore give the appearance of being drought tolerant. 

                You cannot train roots to grow deep.  Roots will grow as deep as they can breathe.  A UC Davis study of root depth in an Almond orchard subjected to deep, infrequent irrigation compared to light, frequent irrigation gave (at least to the researchers) unexpected results.  Daily, light irrigations resulted in a deeper root system. 

                In general the soils in Orange County absorb water at the rate of ¼” to 1/8” per hour.  If using sprinklers the longest times each zone should be on to avoid runoff and/or uneven absorption is only 4-5 minutes, less if watering a steep slope.  Each zone can be watered more than once per day (at least 1 hour apart) as required. 

                There are areas in Southern California where the coarse soils can absorb water at a tremendous rate.  Many of these gardens can get by with one long irrigation period per week.  Be aware that irrigation is less efficient if the water percolates much deeper than the root system.  I am not yet convinced that plants would rather have their weekly rationing of water applied all at one time rather than small portions throughout the week. 

                For grass lawns the average number of minutes of sprinkler irrigation per week is as low as 4 minutes in winter to as many as 50 minutes in summer.  During the hottest summer weather a lawn may require 3 watering periods per day.  Most shrubs and trees require about 1/3 less water. 

                You can utilize an old farmer method in order to measure moisture in the ground (if the water is being applied to the surface).  A 4’ long piece of rebar or similar metal rod is pushed by hand into the ground.  The depth to which you can push it is directly related to the depth of moist soil.  It is very difficult to push a stick or rod into dry soil.  If you can push the rebar into the ground 12” the soil contains ample moisture to 12” deep.  Locally most plant roots live in the top 12” of soil. 

                Grass lawns require 12-18” of moisture.  Most grasses start looking stressed at less than 8” and show browning at 6”.  A Tall Fescue lawn goes totally dormant at less than 4”.  Brown patches on lawns in summer are commonly due to lack of moisture, resulting from not watering frequently enough usually accompanied by applying water faster than it could be absorbed. 

Dormant (brown) lawns are not necessarily dead.  Research shows that all grasses commonly used as a lawn can be dry and dormant for at least a 3 month period, and recover fully when moisture is restored.  This capability can make grass lawns valuable where drought is eminent, since they can be left all summer without irrigation. 

                In Agriculture the goal is a consistently moist soil.  With many types of fruiting plants a wildly fluctuating moisture level results in small fruit or cracked fruit.  There is a vineyard in California’s Central Valley that irrigates with an underground drip system up to 18 times per day, each hour the temperature was above 80°F.  Sensors and computers would establish how much water was used during the last hour.  They were able to save about 30% on water without any loss of crop.  Most modern orchards water daily during hot weather. 

                A current theory of orchard irrigation is to “top off the tank” rather than allow the soil to run dry. 

                With all plants the amount of water they use increases with size.  A full size Citrus in the middle of summer will commonly use 50 gallons of water per day.  Mature shade trees can use 100 gallons of water per day. 

                Apparently, with actively growing or producing plants there is little net loss of water when plants are irrigated mid-day compared to mid-night.  A lawn evaporates water (transpires) faster than a pool of water covering the same area.  Watering a plant at mid-day will cool it tremendously and significantly lower the transpiration rate for a short period.  Water evaporating off the ground near plants also lowers their transpiration rate. 

                Leaves and flowers that stay wet for long periods (3 hours or more) can get diseased (leaf spot, foliage blight, rust).  If you have a choice it is best have the sprinklers go on when the foliage will dry quickly.  During hot weather this can by any time day or night.  During mild weather the watering should be done between mid morning and noon. 

                Plants react in different ways to dryness.  With most plants the leaves will loose turgidity and wilt with the foliage color appearing less green and/or glossy.  Some plants will fold or roll their leaves.  If kept dry over an extended period the leaves tend to develop dead, dry tissue either at the leaf tip or between the veins.  Dryness is usually expressed over the entire plant evenly, although areas most exposed to heat usually show the strongest symptoms.  If dry foliage is only seen on a few isolated branches the problem is usually due to disease.